№ 4 (2025)
Special Theme of the Issue: Ethnography of Performing Arts (guest editor S.I. Ryzhakova)
Ethnography of Dance and Ritual Theatre: New Formats of Traditional Performances
Аннотация
The article is a brief introduction to the issue’s special theme focusing on the “Ethnography of Performing Arts”. This collection of articles is dedicated to the ethnography of dance and ritual theatre. It presents the contributions by M.V. Osipova (who analyzes traditional Ainu dance practices in contemporary Japan), S.I. Ryzhakova (an article on the transformation of martial practices into dance and stage performances in India), A.V. Kinyaeva (a study of Tazi’a phenomena in Iran and India), A.A. Glazovsksaya and S.V. Alferov (respectively, Irish and Scotish dances as both national and global phenomena) and characterizes them in the context of research into the performing arts of the particular communities and cultures in different countries of the world.
5-8
Ainu Traditional Dance as an Exhibit of Museum Culture and as an Element of Ethnic Tourism
Аннотация
Ainu traditional dance is an integral part of folk culture, which is connected with rituals, songs and music. Nowadays, however, real rituals are not carried out and the dance that used to accompany them has turned into a cultural phenomenon which has absorbed both traditional content and new elements. Ainu dance has become a spectacular art; it is being revived and supported in museum complexes in Hokkaido, and the process of its museumification is underway. The dance is turning into a kind of museum exhibit, which requires “ethnographic accuracy” in its performance. But museums are institutions intended for the public, and they are part of the modern tourism industry. Therefore, the problem of the purposes and scope of reproducing authentic material arises. On the other hand, the dance should be spectacular and understandable to different groups of spectators. The article attempts to analyze the conditions that were instrumental in transforming the Ainu ritual dance into an exhibit of museum culture and the ways of its transition into an element of ethnic tourism.
9-21
Warrior Exercises That Become a Dance: Kalarippayattu, Thang-Ta, Raibenshe, Natua in Today's India
Аннотация
Kinetic practices, which until recently were part of the daily internal practice of particular groups involved in martial art in India, are now coming onto the stage, have formed and continue to form a new format for their existence, concentrating on presentation to an audience – both inside the country, at various seminars and festivals, and broadly in the international arena. The traditions of Kalarippayattu, Thang-ta, Raibenshe and Natua are good examples of martial arts, whose sets of exercises that in today’s India are gradually becoming dance or stage performance. Drawing on extensive ethnographic material collected during the expeditions in 2002–2025 in India (West Bengal, Kerala and Manipur), I describe the changes that occurred in traditional martial practices in the 20th century. Each of the traditions analysed was until recently associated with a specific caste community and was practised in gymnasiums (such as the kalari of Kerala) or in the open air, with no audience intended for the application of the skills acquired. However, the change in the socio-economic picture and all the conditions of life, which became evident in the middle of the 20th century, required a transformation of the professional skills of the martial communities and the ways of their usage.
22-43
The Ta'ziyeh: Sacred Act of Muslims in India and Iran
Аннотация
The annual commemorations of Imam Hussein and his companions, who have tragically died in Karbala in 680, are an important part of the religious life of Shia Muslims around the globe. In various regions complex rituals have emerged aiming at collective reproduction and recreation of the events of Karbala. The word Taʻziyeh means “condolence” in Arabic. In Iranian culture, Taʻziyeh is known as a passion play inspired by the tragic death of Hussein. In South Asia and the Caribbean, the word “taziya” refers to miniature models of the mausoleums of Husain, used in ritual processions held in the month of Muharram. The ritual actions associated with Taʻziyeh have absorbed many local traditions. The traditions of the Shia communities of Northern India (particularly that of Lucknow) and Iran are particularly interesting for their undeniable connection and prominent differences. Comparing the traditions of the Shia communities in India and Iran, I will consider the transformation of the performing arts associated with Taʻziyeh, and will attempt to trace how grief is expressed within the framework of performing rituals associated with Taʻziyeh.
44-56
Irish Dance in the Modern World: Setting of Pub, Competition, and Stage
Аннотация
Ireland’s image in mass culture is closely associated with Irish dances, which are one of the country’s distinctive symbols. As a result of the success of the touring dance show “Riverdance” in 1994, Irish dances have long ceased to be considered to be only “Irish”. The Irish Dance World Championships are attended by over 6,000 dancers from around 30 countries. Riverdance still remains one of Ireland’s most profitable export products. The dance form that we see today on the stage, associated with Ireland, was developed at the beginning of the 20th century. This was a result of the country's quest for independence. Since then, however, its functions have changed in the modern world. When this dance became widely known on the global stage during a period of economic boom (the effect referred to as the Celtic Tiger), it became a reflection of global “western” trends that were completely opposed to established notions of how the dance should be performed: “past, catholic, rural” has been modified into a Broadway-style performance. This article investigates how a local cultural phenomenon, which is considered “folk dance” on stage, became an object of commodification in the 21st century, as well as the changes it has undergone (and continues to undergo).
57-73
Continuity and Change in the Scottish Dancing Tradition in the 19th-21st Centuries as Exemplified by the "Reel of Tulloch"
Аннотация
Integrating a wealth of historical and ethnographic data from various regions of Scotland and beyond, the article examines the dynamics of continuity and change within the frame of over 200 years of the Scottish dancing tradition, exemplified by the Reel of Tulloch, a variation of one of the four main dances performed at Highland dancing competitions worldwide. In particular, the article focuses on the historical and cultural significance of the instances transforming the dance repertoire linked to its inclusion into the competitive programme of the Highland Games in the 19th century and the regulation of technique and dance steps in the middle of the 20th century. The role of cross-generational ties in the preservation and development of Scottish dancing is emphasized as well. A blend of dance semiotics and historical anthropology allows us to examine the ethnocultural significance of dancing from different perspectives and reach a balance between a constructivist view of Scottish dancing as an “invented tradition”, on the one hand, and experiences of mutually enriching creative collaboration between numerous generations of dancers, teachers, judges, musicians and spectators, on the other.
74-90
Archival Research
The Legend of the Defense of Fort Ross by the Kashaya Indians
Аннотация
The article is a publication and study of a recently discovered legend about the defense of the former Russian fortress Ross (now Fort Ross) by the Californian Kashaya Indians, told by the spiritual leader of the Kashaya Essie Parrish in the 20th century. The published text is analyzed in the article from the standpoint of today’s knowledge about the history of Fort Ross. The article notes the discrepancy between a number of important points of the legend and historical facts; however, in the author’s opinion, it is possible that the plot core of this story reflects an undocumented event that could have taken place only in the very early period after the sale of Ross, in early 1842. At the same time, regardless of its historical authenticity, the published legend is an important fact of the historical self-awareness of the Kashaya, whose ethnic history, which took place under the conditions of Russian colonization, is distinguished by great originality.
91-108
Boris Matveyevich Sokolov and Museum Work in the USSR of the 1920s
Аннотация
Introducing and examining an archival document discovered at the Russian State Archive of Literature and Art, the article discusses the academic career of Boris Matveevich Sokolov, a remarkable scholar of Russian ethnography and folklore, whose efforts were instrumental in shaping museum work in the Soviet Union of the 1920s. The archival document casts light on various aspects of the development of museums as academic institutions in the early USSR. It helps us better understand the new emerging concept of ethnographic museum in particular, and Stalin’s idea of science based on the centralized system of state management in general. It further shows Sokolov as a scholar of this new Soviet era, who has an active social stance and proactively leads the Central Ethnographic Museum in Moscow as director, engaging in teaching and popularizing science for the public. In a sense, this unique archival document may be viewed as an autobiographic commentary on Sokolov’s activities as the museum’s manager, which have been little explored and studied to date.
109-129
A 1953 Memo of the Department of Science and Culture of the Central Committee of the CPSU on Measures for Improving the Work of the Journal Sovetskaia Etnografiia
Аннотация
In this article, I dive into examination of an archival document shedding light on the mid-twentieth century editorial politics of the journal Sovetskaia etnografiia and, more generally, on the changes in interpreting Soviet ethnography’s key subjects and themes during the period of ideological debates in the late Stalin era. This is a memo which was prepared by the Department of Science and Culture of the Central Committee of USSR’s Communist Party in 1953 as an outcome of the assessment of work and activities of the journal. That assessment was initiated by the Division of History and Philosophy of the Russian Academy of Sciences after the decisions on national culture were issued at the 19th Congress of the Communist Party. It was also timed to the publication of Stalin’s writings on the economic problems of socialism and the place of Marxism in language studies. The very form of the memo and its specific omissions and misrepresentations let us better understand the currents of competition in Soviet academia in the 1950s. I argue that the memo’s target was Sergei Tolstov, then chief editor of the journal and director of the Institute of Ethnography of the Russian Academy of Sciences.
130-148
Research Articles
Tabarnia: A Political Game of "Imagined Community"
Аннотация
In the 2010s, a social movement emerged in Catalonia, inspired by the desire of a large group of residents of this autonomous region of Spain to resist regional separatists. The movement's participants insist on a deep and comprehensive - including cultural, linguistic, and historical - uniqueness of the inhabitants of the Barcelona and Tarragona area (Tabarnia) in comparison with other Catalans. On these grounds, they demand that they be recognized as a special people and that Tabarnia be separated from Catalonia as an autonomous community, which would remain part of the country regardless of the future fate of Catalonia. The article examines the process of constructing a new "imaginary community" and forming a sense of special identity in a population. It discusses the arguments, techniques, and technologies used in this case, considering the features dictated by the Spanish historical and political tradition, and shows the dependence of the development of events on the changing political context.
149-163
Kudel-Drem: An Interpretation of the Red Hill Rituals among the Don Cossacks
Аннотация
The article provides a general description of the rituals of the Red Hill among the Don Cossacks and a detailed reconstruction of the Kudel ritual, recorded by the author in the village of Lukovskaya, Nekhaevsky District, Volgograd Region, in 2008. This ritual was performed here on the Red Hill until the mid-1980s. Based on her field materials, the testimonies of other folklorists, and previously published texts of round dance songs related to spinning and weaving, the author provides an interpretation of this ritual, identifies the main features of the collective image of Kudel-Drem, and shows its connection with the other world and the souls of deceased girls of marriageable age. In this case, we are talking about a specific category of girls who, during their lifetime, had committed “wrong” actions, such as neglecting their feminine crafts and engaging in premarital relationships. According to popular beliefs, the unspent life force (share) of these deceased individuals should be included in the total life force/share of the girls of marriageable age in a particular village. In addition, the Kudel ritual served as a socializing/educational function, symbolically marking the transition between different time periods and associated collective activities among young people.
164-184
Biology and Culture: Ethnographic and Anthropological Perspectives on Gene-Culture Coevolution
Аннотация
This article provides an interdisciplinary analysis of the interaction between genetic, neural, and cultural factors underlying key human capacities such as language, ritual, art, and complex social organization. The study is based on the concept of gene-culture coevolution, which demonstrates that culture can generate selective pressures while also being shaped by biological influences, forming a dynamic feedback loop between the two. Ethnographic examples from diverse contexts – including Andean and Tibetan highland societies, Nicaraguan sign languages, Aboriginal Australian practices, and Ugandan educational reforms – illustrate the variety of adaptive strategies. These cases show how culture can both compensate for and reinforce biological influences. Published field data on topics such as high-altitude adaptation, linguistic environments, and ritual systems highlight the importance of an interdisciplinary approach that integrates genetics, neurobiology, ethnography, and cultural anthropology. In conclusion, the study emphasizes that overcoming the simplistic nature versus nurture dichotomy requires acknowledging the synergy between biological and cultural mechanisms that drive the coevolution of cognitive and social capacities in Homo sapiens, particularly in the context of globalization and technological advancement.
185-206
Book Reviews and Critiques
Heritage, Politics, and the Politics of Heritage: A Review of The Routledge International Handbook of Heritage and Politics, edited by G. Bozoğlu, G. Campbell, L. Smith, and C. Whitehead
207-212
Unattained West, Lost East: A Review of Greece Between East and West: Culture and Geopolitics, edited by R. Pine
213-218
Unknown Ethnography of the Far East: A Review of Tungusic Peoples of the Aldano-Maiskii and Aiano-Okhotskii Districts, by V.N. Vasiliev
219-224
